ANSI BSR Upholds Appeal of AFDE Member Andrew Sulner, MSFS, JD, finding the AAFS Academy Standards Board (ASB) Violated ANSI Essential Requirements
Michimich.com/10339045

NEW YORK - Michimich -- ANSI BSR Upholds Appeal of AFDE Member Andrew Sulner, MSFS, JD, finding that the AAFS Academy Standards Board (ASB) Violated ANSI Essential Requirements for Due Process

NEW YORK, N.Y., August 24, 2026 — The Association of Forensic Document Examiners (AFDE) is pleased to announce the recent success of one of its members, Andrew Sulner, MSFS, J.D. (Forensic Document Examinations, LLC) in his appeal of the ANSI BSR's approval of ASB 155 Standard for Minimum Training Requirements for Forensic Document Examiners as an American National Standard (ANS).

Minimum Training Requirements for Forensic Document Examiners were first published in 2005 by ASTM.  When the forensic document examination committee of ASTM was disbanded in 2012 that standard transferred to the FBI-funded SWGDOC, which adopted the ASTM training standard verbatim in 2013.  Those standards set the duration for training at 4000 hours (two years of full time training) and allowed an equivalent part-time training program of up to four years in duration.  This was important because in the private sector, the trainer and trainee are typically already working and can not devote full-time efforts to a training program.  In governmental agencies (FBI, IRS, State Crime Labs, etc.), trainers and trainees are paid employees.

More on Michimich.com

• Work 365 Expands Distributor Integrations with Companial for Microsoft Partners
• ACTIQO Launches Free Research Hub to Help Parents Navigate the Cost & Pressure of Kids' Activities
• Guardian Data Opens 42,000-Square-Foot Moonachie Facility, Doubling New Jersey Capacity
• EverNew Roofing Partners With Habitat for Humanity to Install New Roof on Mount Clemens Home
• Hillside Terrace Senior Living Highlights Senior-Friendly Fall Activities Around Ann Arbor

What caught Mr. Sulner's attention and caused him great concern with the proposed ASB Standard 155 is that it would have made it substantially impossible for new FDEs to emerge out of the private sector.  The ASB 155 standard states, "A trainee may or may not be a salaried employee and is expected to work almost daily with the instructor in their laboratory or office."   The concept of equivalent part-time training is not mentioned, and the only allowance to deviate from the defined duration is for "exigent circumstances," and even then, the extension can be no longer than one year. (emphasis added)

The ANSI BSR found for the Appellant, Mr. Sulner, on the issue of dominance, finding that the American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) had failed to investigate a written claim of dominance made to it, which it was obligated to do. The ANSI BSR specifically noted that "AAFS's evidentiary submission in support of ASB 155's approval did not establish that [Mr. Sulner's] written claim of dominance was ever investigated or considered, as required" by Sections 1.0, 1.2, and 2.2 of the ANSI Essential Requirements for Due Process.

More on Michimich.com

• MI License Lawyer Offers Guidance for Michigan Drivers Facing First-Time OWI and License Issues
• SecureMaine 2026 is Here -- Thursday October 8th!
• Pear Sperling Eggan & Daniels, P.C. Highlights the Importance of Estate Planning After Divorce
• ArborMotion Encourages Drivers to Check Wheel Alignment Before Fall
• HW Foundation Opens Nominations for Inaugural 50 Under 50 in AI; Deadline Oct. 16

The Association of Forensic Document Examiners considers the outcome of Mr. Sulner's appeal a successful one for its members, as well as the broader FDE community and the public. We look forward to working on a training standard that is both procedurally and substantively fair to all industry stakeholders.

Mr. Sulner's July 21, 2026 appeal letter, the ASB response, and the August 21, 2026 decision of the ANSI BSR Appeals Panel are available at https://afde.org.